Have you ever had one of those days where you just wanted to hit the “delete” key on your entire life? That’s exactly where we find Polly Potter at the start of The Accidental Rewrite by Milly Johnson. Honestly, calling her life a mess is an understatement—it was more like the perfect recipe for burnout I discovered reading this novel for this review. This story is the perfect escapist journey for anyone who has ever dreamed of starting over with a clean slate.
Disclaimer: Some links found on this page might be affiliate links. If you click an affiliate link and make a purchase, we may earn a commission. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
The Life Polly Needed to Leave Behind
Polly was stuck with a jerk of a boss who walked all over her, and a partner, Chris, who basically treated her like an unappreciated live-in maid. Aside from Chris’s son, Will, who was really the only bright spot, his family was just as unwelcoming. Polly was completely drained from always putting everyone else first, and her only escape was the novel she was writing about a fearless, bold woman named Sabrina Anderson.
Why I’m Firmly Team Sabrina
But then, fate steps in with a literal “bump” on the head. Polly suffers a concussion that leaves her stranded on the Yorkshire coast. She wakes up believing she is Sabrina, a character she created in creative writing. And let me tell you, I am 100% Team Sabrina! Seeing her chance to get a new beginning was so satisfying. As Sabrina, she finally embodies all the qualities she’s always longed for: she is fearless, capable, and respected. It’s the ultimate fantasy because it asks the question: what if you could actually stop writing the life you want and just start living it?
Finding Home (and Love) in a Seaside Italian Kitchen
She finds herself taken in by this loud, wonderful Italian family who runs a local restaurant, and the “found family” vibes are just perfection. Between the sea air and the seagulls, we meet Teddy, the warmhearted son of her landlady. The romance between Sabrina and Teddy is just the icing on the cake. Unlike her past relationship with the “man-child” Chris, this is built on mutual respect and shared passion. Teddy sees Sabrina for who she truly is, and their chemistry makes you root for her new life even harder.
My Final Verdict
Watching her memory slowly trickle back while her heart is tied to this new life kept me turning the pages. This book is witty, moving, and the greatest reminder that we all have the power to rewrite our own endings. If you need a vacation for your soul, this is the British rom-com for you. Check this contemporary romance novel out!
P.S. If this plot sounds familiar, this novel was originally published in Britain back in 2024 under the title Together, Again. This heartwarming contemporary romance written by Milly Johnson is the same touching story, just with a shiny new name The Accidental Rewrite for the US debut!
Thanks to Harper Muse and HarperCollins for this #gifted book for this review.
