If there’s one thing we know about Lindsey Norris, it’s that she is fiercely persistent, a quality that shines throughout this Booking for Trouble review. In this 16th installment of Jenn McKinlay’s Library Lover’s Mystery series, our favorite library director is taking to the water with her brand-new “book-boat.” Lindsey’s mission to reach the isolated Split Islands is both heartwarming and heroic; despite a decades-old family feud threatening her deliveries, she remains inspired by the legacy of traditional land-based bookmobiles.
Disclaimer: Some links found on this page might be affiliate links. If you click an affiliate link and make a purchase, we may earn a commission. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
A Librarian on a Mission (and a Boat!)
I absolutely loved the imagery of Lindsey navigating the Connecticut coast. It’s such a clever, modern spin on the Library Lover’s Mystery series, and it really highlights Lindsey’s “all-hands-on-deck” attitude toward literacy. While the families on the Split Islands are physically isolated by water and socially isolated by a bitter, long-standing feud, Lindsey views these barriers as mere footnotes. Her determination to deliver books to every reader, regardless of the drama surrounding them, is exactly why she remains one of my favorite cozy mystery protagonists.
A Battle on Land and Sea
As if navigating the choppy waters of the Split Islands wasn’t enough, Lindsey is also facing a storm back at the town hall. Councilman Gideon Trask is determined to cut the library budget, and he’s not exactly a fan of Lindsey’s “extravagant” book-boat dreams. This added pressure makes her mission feel even more urgent—she isn’t just delivering books; she’s fighting to prove to the town council that the library is a vital, unbreakable lifeline for the entire community.
When Small-Town Drama Hits High Seas
Of course, it wouldn’t be a Briar Creek mystery without a bit of trouble! Things take a dark turn when Lindsey and her husband, Mike Sullivan, discovery of a body on a rocky island outcropping. Suddenly, Lindsey’s peaceful book deliveries turn into a high-stakes murder investigation.
The discovery reignites hostilities between the two rival families who own the islands, which causes more tension to rise. McKinlay does a fantastic job showing how long-buried secrets bubble to the surface when a crime is committed. As this small-town amateur sleuth navigates literal and metaphorical treacherous waters, she has to use her best weapon and her research skills to solve the case before her book-boat dreams are sunk.
The Heart of Briar Creek: Friends and Family
What really makes this book shine is the support system surrounding Lindsey that gives this book such heart. One of the best parts of returning to this series is catching up with the “crafternoon” crew and the library staff.
Mike Sullivan: Lindsey’s husband and boat captain that operates a water taxi business provides a steady, protective presence that balances out Lindsey’s high-energy sleuthing. They make a formidable team on and off the water.
The Community: The bickering between the island families adds a layer of “Romeo and Juliet” style drama that keeps the plot moving, while the library regulars provide the humor and heart we’ve come to expect from Briar Creek.
The Verdict
If you’re looking for a mystery where the protagonist’s passion for her community is just as strong as the investigative plot, Booking for Trouble shared in this review will bring a smile to your face. Check this delightful book out!
Thanks to Berkley (Penguin Random House) for this #gifted book for this review.
